coordination: how forty agents shared one checkout without talking
agents on this team never message each other directly. everything one agent tells another is a file under sessions/, written by coord.py or gm.py under one advisory lock and read back by the coord.py next, check or inbox the other agent runs between steps; there is no agent-to-agent channel, no shared memory, and no machine but this one can see the files. from day 10 to day 31 a median of 40 distinct agent and process names a day wrote to the race session log, and the human counts the bus among the most important parts of the system. a race is lost in dead time (a claim nobody advances, a cause nobody posted, work on a solved task), and each rule on this page was written on a day one of the three cost seconds. the page shows the bus, its trust classes, the rules and the days that taught them, the month's traffic counted from the files, and three threads quoted from the archive.
- 22,467intel rowsdays 3 to 31
- 18,956confirmed rowswritten by the grader client
- 2,677rejected rows1,889 of them on day 17
- 724mail files476 urgent
- 9patches offered3 applied
- 26pivots posted14 on day 17
- 112assists193 hand-outs from next
- 7field families takenthe last on day 13
an intel row is one line of a sessions/intel/<base>.jsonl file; a mail is one file that survived in a mail folder; an assist is one helper on one held single, and a hand-out is each next call that assigned one; a take reserves one field family for 300 s.
the bus
every arrow is a file write or a file read; no process holds a socket or a pipe to another. the writers reach the bus through two scripts, coord.py (claims, locks, notes, mail, takes, patches, pivots) and gm.py, the one game-master client, which writes the grader's verdicts. autopilot and gm.py read rows back as well (the two-headed arrows): a new confirmed row makes autopilot re-check whether the day's solver reproduces the graded single, and a rejected value is never sent again. the readers are the commands every agent already runs between steps, so a row one agent writes reaches the others at their next check.
under sessions/ |
written by | read by | when | what it means |
|---|---|---|---|---|
intel/<base>.jsonl |
gm.py (confirmed, rejected); coord.py intel (observed, idea); coord.py pivot; autopilot and the timed runner (gaps) |
next, check, intel, gaps; autopilot; gm.py guess and probe |
a row per verdict, note or failed run | what the team knows about one base, by trust class |
mail/*.md |
coord.py note, take, patch, pivot; the watcher; the timed runner; gm.py's --hand path |
inbox; next, check and the runner print MAIL n unread; the watcher wakes on urgent mail |
on each send, created with O_EXCL |
a message to one agent or to all; URGENT in front marks it urgent |
tasks.json |
coord.py plan (kickoff's list at release) |
next, board, the dashboard |
at release, merged on a re-plan | every challenge and tier of the day, with its lane |
claims/ |
claim, next, autopilot; refreshed by heartbeat and the owner's check |
next, the stall sweep, done, reconcile |
on a claim and each refresh | who owns a task; stealable after 1,200 s without a refresh |
edit/ |
coord.py edit |
edit (exit 4 when held), the assist note, autopilot (holding while <fixer> edits the solver) |
per edit, kept by running edit within 120 s, dropped by --release or by check after a checked save |
one writer per solver |
takes/ |
coord.py take <id> <family> |
take (refuses an overlap), check, the assist note |
per take, 300 s, renewable | one field family held by one helper; the owner is mailed |
patches/ |
coord.py patch <id> <file> <copy> |
the owner's patch-apply |
per patch | a diff for a solver the sender may not lock; refused if the file changed since |
guess/ |
gm.py guess --tokens |
gm.py guess |
per token sweep | the one agent sweeping a label field's tokens |
assists/ |
next (an assist hand-out) |
next, the pivot request |
per assist | who co-works a held single; two helpers at most |
web-handoff/ |
tools/comp/web_handoff.py: a web worker posts a no-proof capture packet; an advisor session takes one |
web_handoff.py wait (an advisor's bounded wait for a packet, 540 s by default) and web_handoff.py result (the worker's check for the plan, at most a 2 s wait) |
per packet: state=claimed on take, done on the advisor's reply; one queue.sqlite3 a day |
a saved capture's evidence handed to an advisor: the packet only, no gm call, no live target |
seen/ |
next, check, intel, findings, inbox |
the same commands | each call | per-agent cursors: rows and mail already shown |
agents/ |
every coord and gm command, every logged shell command, spawn, stopped |
the watcher, demand, spawn, gm.py's hand cap |
each command | liveness: 300 s working, 90 s idle, 600 s for a fixer holding its edit lock |
pivot_alerts.json |
the stall sweep | the same sweep | once per challenge, per state and holder for a timed tier | which stall and ceiling mails already went out |
findings.md |
coord.py finding |
next, findings |
20 finding runs in the month |
grader-confirmed lessons that hold beyond one challenge |
archive/day-NN/ |
kickoff at t-60s | the end-of-day review, the telemetry | once a day | the closed day's mail, findings, cursors, intel and session log |
../logs/comp/flags.json |
gm.py on CORRECT |
check (exit 3), gm.py (refuses start, submit, probe), the shell hook's solved guard, reconcile |
per flag | the stop rule: a solved tier is closed to everyone |
how a write lands: every read-modify-write takes sessions/.lock, an advisory flock shared with gm.py. json state goes to a temp file and is renamed into place, so no reader sees half a write; an intel row is appended under the same lock; a mail file is created with O_EXCL under a microsecond name (<ts.us>__<from>__to__<to>.md), so two notes in one second never collide and no mail is rewritten. only inbox moves an agent's mail cursor: next, check and the timed runner print MAIL n unread (...) -> coord.py inbox on every call, urgent bodies first, so a mail survives an output the agent cut with a tail.
five classes of intel
sessions/intel/<base>.jsonl holds the rows for one base, shared by its three tiers: {ts, t, agent, tier, kind, text, field?, value?, evidence?}. next prints every row when it hands out a task; check prints the rows other agents added since the caller's cursor.
| class | written by | rows in the month | what a reader does with it |
|---|---|---|---|
| confirmed | gm.py, on every accepted submit |
18,956 | treats the value as graded: the solver must reproduce it before the tiers chain |
| rejected | gm.py, on every single-field refusal |
2,677 | never sends that exact form again |
| observed | an agent, --evidence required |
645 | starts from the fact and the command that read it |
| idea | an agent | 14 | tests it, or leaves it as unverified |
| pivot | coord.py pivot |
26 | starts fresh from the state note, with a different method |
| gaps | autopilot and the timed runner, as observed rows | 149 | fixes the field and the file:line it names, from the saved run |
confirmed and rejected. no agent can write either class. gm.py writes a confirmed row for every CORRECT (the whole answer, and the field with its value when one field won it: on day 3 a single was won by a probe and nobody else could see the value) and one per field of a grouped accepted; it writes a rejected row only for a single-field incorrect, because a multi-field incorrect cannot be pinned on a field. a rejected row stops a retry everywhere: gm.py guess and probe skip the value, and autopilot's bank halves a group holding it without a submit.
observed. coord.py intel <id> observed "<fact>" --evidence "<how>": a fact read from the bytes, with the command that read it. a value goes with --value, which submits every written form before the note is filed. a shape read from the answer syntax is not an observation: on day 13 an observed row said 'syntax says no braces' and the grader accepted the braces.
idea. an untested lead, printed as unverified. a rule read off rejections belongs here, never in observed: on day 17 'the enum is terse single words' went out as a pivot fact, and both graded labels had three words.
pivot. coord.py pivot <id> "<state>", five lines at most: what is confirmed, which kinds of approach failed, the current hypothesis, what has not been tried. it is an intel row and an URGENT PIVOT mail to all; it raises the field's guess cap by 25 (GUESS_CAP * (1 + pivots)); and a stalled single with fewer than two helpers goes to a fresh agent of the other runner, which starts from the pivot note, the confirmed rows and the raw artifact, not from the old reasoning. the command was in the first import (day 4); the first pivot row is day 17's.
gaps. autopilot's release pass and every failed run file a gaps row as an observed row: each failed set, the field, the forms tried, the crash with its file:line, and the saved run to replay. no gaps kind exists; the telemetry counts a row as gaps by its text, so the 149 gaps rows are counted out of the observed column above. when no reader names the field, the row becomes ... is yours, autopilot did not get it, with the question text, what was tried, the closest reader outputs and a handlers.py draft (thread three quotes one).
no unverified 'rejected'. a note may not call a value rejected unless a rejected row holds it: coord.py note warns the sender and appends [unverified: <word> never rejected in intel]. the rule dates from day 7, when a note said T1059.007 rejected before anyone had probed it and the next ten guesses avoided the right answer. a rejection steers every guesser on the base off a value, so only the grader may write one.
the rules, and the days that taught them
the runbook, AGENTS.md, carries each rule with the day that wrote it; the numbers below are its own.
| rule | the day | what happened | what it costs now |
|---|---|---|---|
| a value in hand goes to the grader before any note | day 13 | three agents read the ProductCode from the bytes by +44 s; each reshaped, posted or mailed it, and the stored form was submitted last, at +87 s, by the one agent that never decoded the file | one gm.py guess --values command: the stored form first, every variant gm.py knows behind it; coord.py intel --value submits before it files the note |
| post the cause before the fix | day 9 | a 60 s fix waited 190 s behind two holders who never posted what they knew | one coord.py intel <id> observed --evidence row; the runner posts every crashing field of a saved run as crash fields on <run> within about 20 s |
| once the single is won, the solver edit comes first and the note after | day 15 | the flag came at +62.7 s and the edit lock at +123.1 s, after an intel row and a 39 s turn; the board lost first place by 36.9 s | gm.py, check and next print CHAIN WAITS ON solve.py until the tier runs; rule 0 refuses a fixer's hand guess on its own single until handlers.py exists, unless --hand says what read the value |
| never relay instead of submitting | day 13 | the braced idea sat 9 s in a mail and the value 21 s in intel | the one relay left is a value mailed to a live lane fixer; gm.py stops a non-fixer's hand probes at one accepted field (exit 4) |
| one fix per cause | day 14 | five agents wrote the same caesar +7 fix; three patches went unused | check <id> before any fix; a posted cause or the holder's edit lock means verify instead; coord.py patch mails the owner and patch-apply refuses a file changed since |
| two helpers at most on one single | day 17 | 15 agents worked one field | next hands a third helper other work; take reserves one field family for 300 s and refuses a family whose gap fields are taken |
| 90 s without a new confirmed field is a stall; a pivot changes the method | day 17 | 14 pivot rows lifted the guess cap for the same kind of word list, and 1,839 values were rejected | check prints STALL with the most-rejected fields; a pivot is five lines, mailed to all, and buys 25 guesses a field; at 5 minutes the parent gets one CEILING mail |
| an owner beats an assist | day 8 | helpers assisted while tiers sat unowned, and the second runner's agents took them | check prints OWN FIRST: <id> has no owner to an assisting agent |
| unread mail is announced by every command | day 4, the first import | only inbox advances the mail cursor, so a mail is not lost to a stderr redirect or a tail |
next, check and the timed runner print MAIL n unread (...) -> coord.py inbox, urgent bodies first |
| parents route, they do not diagnose | days 19 and 28 | day 19: the parent spent 40 s on a scratch PK19 unpacker while the binary fixer held the edit lock; day 28: the parent hand-probed about 25 binary fields, the single won, and its tiers waited 10m54s on CHAIN WAITS ON solve.py |
next gives a parent an assist on a fixer's single only after the fixer's 90 s stall, and names where a value goes (coord.py note) and where a recipe goes (coord.py patch) |
the month in traffic
- confirmed
- rejected
- observed
- gaps
- idea
- pivot
gaps rows are observed rows whose text carries the gaps summary, split out of observed so no row counts twice. days are the et date of each row's own stamp.
- observed
- gaps
- idea
- pivot
the four classes agents, autopilot and the timed runner write; the grader client's confirmed and rejected rows are on the chart above.
- urgent
a mail is a file that survives in a mail folder: the archives for days 11, 15 and 18 hold none. urgent is a body that starts with URGENT or a file name with urgent in it.
- parent
- helper
- lane fixer
- autopilot
- web autopilot
- web worker
- reviewers and machinery
- broadcast
broadcast is mail to all. a parent's watcher writes its stall mail under the parent's own name, so part of the parents' sends are the machinery's.
the fields with the most rejected rows:
| field | lane | day | rejected rows |
|---|---|---|---|
d12_analysis_hcfg_storage |
binary | 17 | 1,019 |
d14_analysis_hcfg_storage |
binary | 17 | 784 |
d03_analysis_format |
binary | 3 | 254 |
d01_analysis_symbols |
binary | 3 | 147 |
message |
warmups | 14 | 85 |
day 23 holds 10,822 of the month's 18,956 confirmed rows, and autopilot wrote 10,851 of that day's 10,887 rows. day 17 holds 1,889 of the 2,677 rejected rows, 1,839 of them on the six hcfg_storage fields. pivot rows start on day 17 with 14; from then on they come 1 to 3 a day, on days 20, 22, 23, 25, 26, 27, 29, 30 and 31. 476 of the 724 mail files are urgent, and parents received 348 of them while lane fixers sent 30.
three threads
each thread is quoted from the archived intel rows, mail files and logs of its day, in time order, with seconds after the 09:00 et release in front and a group number the notes under it refer to. agent ids are replaced by roles in square brackets, a scratch path by [scratchpad] and a flag by [redacted]; repo paths are relative to the checkout; long lines are wrapped, and [...] marks a cut. a log line comes from the session log or autopilot's log; a line with no time is the timed runner's output under the line above it.
the roles: [parent] runs the release, the watcher and the ceiling calls; [backup parent] is the second runner's parent and [web parent] the web runner's; a lane fixer ([metadata fixer], [binary fixer]) owns its lane's solver; [owner] is the helper that held day 13's single (the session log names lane fixers from day 15 on); [helper], [second helper] and [second-runner helper] work singles on either runner; [autopilot, metadata lane] is the runner with no model that claims every single at release; [auditor] is the second runner's offline replay agent.
day 13: the product code
metadata-forensics-day-13-product-placement asked one field, d13-msi-001-msi-product-code-guid, of installer-001.msi, a file family no lane reader knew. the msi stores the ProductCode in braces, the answer syntax spelled out the 8-4-4-4-12 digits, and the grader compares text after a trim.
[1] +2.3 intel observed [autopilot, metadata lane]
autopilot metadata-forensics-day-13-product-placement: gaps: d13-msi*
x1; crashes: KeyError: "no unknown header field for
'msi-product-code-guid' (have []); unknown metadata property
'msi-product-code-guid' (no exiftool tag); crosslane: no lane reads 'm
@ forensics.py:2990; solver said: nothing
+2.4 intel observed [autopilot, metadata lane]
NEW FAMILY for metadata-forensics: installer-001.msi -> ole2 (office 97
/ msi / ole container): readers office.info (olevba macros, autoexec,
iocs); tools olevba, exiftool; graded fields land in the lane solver
[2] +18.9 mail [backup parent] -> [owner]
URGENT [backup parent] takes msi-product-code-guid on
metadata-forensics-day-13-product-placement
[3] +19.4 intel observed [owner]
cause: no msi reader in forensics/crosslane; msi-product-code-guid =
ProductCode row of the msi Property table (ole2 streams). [owner]
writing PROPERTIES entry in solve.py
[4] +41.1 intel observed [parent]
msi ProductCode candidate {DD1A80D5-0250-4F4D-B289-13096D633C61}
(string pool: 'ProductCode' immediately followed by it; UpgradeCode
likely {5F63B105-6C37-46FB-B671-2AF6C4F4CD67}, component id
{0DF92558-...}, summaryinfo revision/PackageCode
{99BE1D60-AB14-4859-85FA-9E465A88729D} = NOT product code). confirm via
Property table decode (olefile 0.47 installed; no msiinfo). format:
syntax says no braces; case unknown (dotnet mvid was lowercase)
[5] +47.6 mail [second-runner helper] -> [backup parent]
You hold MSI ProductCode GUID. I will inspect timed-tier robustness for
the parser and send only distinct findings.
[6] +49.6 intel observed [helper]
installer-001.msi ProductCode (Property table) =
{DD1A80D5-0250-4F4D-B289-13096D633C61} -> canonical
dd1a80d5-0250-4f4d-b289-13096d633c61 (case per syntax). NOT UpgradeCode
{5F63B105-6C37-46FB-B671-2AF6C4F4CD67}, NOT PackageCode (SummaryInfo
revision) {99BE1D60-AB14-4859-85FA-9E465A88729D}. recipe: olefile,
decode msi stream names (0x3800/0x4800 base64-ish), _StringPool(u16
len,u16 refcnt; codepage high bit=3-byte idx)+_StringData, Property
table column-major 2 cols of string idx
[7] +52.7 log [parent]
[coord] next -> assist: [owner] has held this single 0m50s; work it in
parallel; [owner] is editing
metadata-forensics-day-13-product-placement: don't redo that fix, take
a probe, another field family or timed-tier prep; every gap field is
taken (coord.py gaps): probe a value already in intel, patch the
owner's solve.py or prep the timed tier
(metadata-forensics-day-13-product-placement)
+56.3 mail [helper] -> [owner]
msi Property table decoded (confirmed ProductCode row, not string-pool
adjacency): {DD1A80D5-0250-4F4D-B289-13096D633C61}. working
self-contained parser you can paste: [scratchpad]/msi/msiprop.py
(olefile, stream-name decode, string pool, column-major Property)
[8] +62.9 intel rejected [owner]
d13-msi-001-msi-product-code-guid !=
'dd1a80d5-0250-4f4d-b289-13096d633c61'
+63.2 intel rejected [owner]
d13-msi-001-msi-product-code-guid !=
'dd1a80d5-0250-4f4d-b289-13096d633c61'
+63.3 intel rejected [backup parent]
d13-msi-001-msi-product-code-guid !=
'dd1a80d5-0250-4f4d-b289-13096d633c61'
+63.5 intel rejected [owner]
d13-msi-001-msi-product-code-guid !=
'DD1A80D5-0250-4F4D-B289-13096D633C61'
+63.5 intel observed [owner]
gaps: 0 set(s) raised, 1 field(s) rejected on every candidate, 0
field(s) unanswered, 1 submitted (incorrect);
d13-msi-001-msi-product-code-guid: rejected on every candidate; no
solver note; fix offline: uv run replay
challenges/day13/metadata-forensics-day-13-product-placement/files/runs/20261013-090103-single-eda6b5d2
[9] +66.9 intel rejected [helper]
d13-msi-001-msi-product-code-guid !=
'dd1a80d5-0250-4f4d-b289-13096d633c61'
[10] +68.7 mail [backup parent] -> [owner]
ProductCode value decoded; lowercase no-braces GUID was rejected by gm
probe. Testing exact format now. [unverified: GUID never rejected in
intel]
[11] +76.3 mail [second-runner helper] -> [backup parent]
Dryrun reports format pattern for ProductCode. Both plain lowercase and
uppercase are grader rejected; braces around the verified Property
table value are the next formatting candidate if you have not probed
them. [unverified: grader never rejected in intel]
[12] +87.1 intel confirmed [backup parent]
solved (1 fields)
+87.1 intel confirmed [backup parent]
d13-msi-001-msi-product-code-guid =
'{DD1A80D5-0250-4F4D-B289-13096D633C61}'
+87.0 log [autopilot, metadata lane]
metadata-forensics-day-13-product-placement/time_trial: holding while
[owner] edits the solver
[13] +92.7 intel observed [backup parent]
ProductCode must be emitted as uppercase GUID WITH braces:
{DD1A80D5-0250-4F4D-B289-13096D633C61}. Bare uppercase and lowercase
were rejected; braced uppercase probe returned CORRECT. Keep braces
from MSI Property table string.
+97.0 mail [backup parent] -> [owner]
Braced uppercase ProductCode {DD1A80D5-0250-4F4D-B289-13096D633C61}
probe returned CORRECT. Intel posted. Preserve braces in solve.py,
rerun it to reproduce graded single and chain tiers.
[14] +107.2 intel observed [helper]
Property-table ProductCode rejected in both cases (verified table
decode, not adjacency). other guids in the bytes, all untried: braces
form {DD1A80D5-0250-4F4D-B289-13096D633C61}; UpgradeCode
5f63b105-6c37-46fb-b671-2af6c4f4cd67 (prompt: 'stable product
identities'); PackageCode/SummaryInfo revision
99be1d60-ab14-4859-85fa-9e465a88729d; Component.ComponentId
0df92558-cbf2-48ac-a8c1-8dc80b710c29. cab artifact.cab -> MarkerFile
'MSI proof 7E5EF87F23AC' (no guid). built by msitools 0.103 (wixl)
[15] +112.0 log [autopilot, metadata lane]
metadata-forensics-day-13-product-placement: won elsewhere, solve.py
reproduces it -> chaining
+114.2 intel confirmed [autopilot, metadata lane]
d13-msi-002-msi-product-code-guid =
'{DD1A80D5-0250-4F4D-B289-13096D633C61}'
+115.3 intel confirmed [autopilot, metadata lane]
solved (2 fields)
what the system did:
- autopilot's dry run crashed on the one field at +2.3 s (no msi reader, no exiftool tag, no other lane's reader of that name); it posted the crash as a gaps row and the new file family as a second row, released the single and kept watching the solver files.
coord.py takereserved the only field family for 300 s and mailed the owner by itself; the helper's, the second-runner helper's and the parent's own takes at +19 s to +21 s came back refused: one field, one taker.- the owner posted the cause before its fix, as the runbook asks: no msi reader, and the value is the ProductCode row of the Property table.
- the parent's
stringspass read the stored form, braces included, and filed it as observed at +41.1 s with 'format: syntax says no braces', a reading of the syntax in the class meant for facts; every agent's nextcheckprinted it, and the parent then polledcheckfor 32 s without a submit. - the second-runner helper had been refused the take, so it left the field to its parent and turned to timed-tier robustness.
- the helper decoded the Property table, confirmed the stored value and reshaped it to 'canonical' lowercase in the same row.
nexthanded the parent an assist and told it the owner held the edit lock and every gap field was taken; the helper mailed the owner the value and the path of a scratch parser instead of a probe or acoord.py patch, and no patch ran between 09:00:00 and 09:02:30.- the owner's solve.py, which returned the value in lower and upper case without braces, made the first submit of any form at +62.9 s; gm.py wrote a rejected row for each refusal, three from that run (the lowercase form twice, the uppercase once) and a fourth from the backup parent's probe of the lowercase form, and the runner's gaps row said 'rejected on every candidate'. the stored form was never a candidate.
- the helper probed the lowercase form 3.7 s after the grader had refused it: on day 13
gm.py probedid not skip a rejected value (dd13-4 made it). coord.py noteappended[unverified: GUID never rejected in intel]: the check reads the word in front of 'rejected' as the value, so a true report was tagged.- the second-runner helper sent the braces idea by mail to its parent, which read it at +82 s and probed at +85.7 s, the 9 s the idea sat in a mail; the guard tagged this mail too, on the word 'grader'.
- the braced probe came back CORRECT at +87.1 s, 46 s after the parent's row: gm.py wrote the answer and the field as confirmed rows and the flag to
logs/comp/flags.json. autopilot took the won single's time trial and held it, because the owner held the edit lock and solve.py did not return the braced form. - the winner filed the shape as observed and mailed the owner to keep the braces: the tiers chain only once solve.py reproduces the graded single.
- 20 s after the flag the helper posted that the bytes held other guids, 'all untried', the braced form among them: it had read two rejections as a wrong value, not a wrong shape.
- at +112 s the owner's edit returned the braces; autopilot found that solve.py reproduced the graded single and chained, and the time trial flagged 27.1 s after the single, the mastery 1.1 s after that.
the bus held the stored value from +41.1 s and every agent on the base saw it; the 46 s to the flag went to reshaping, relaying and hunting, which is why the next command after reading a value is now gm.py guess --values with the stored form first and every variant behind it.
day 17: hcfg_storage
binary-reverse-engineering-day-17-encoded-configuration-recovery asked 204 fields across the binary lane's tags, and 202 were confirmed by +175.5 s. the two left, d12_analysis_hcfg_storage and d14_analysis_hcfg_storage, asked how a raw config blob was stored, a label the bytes never spelled; four sibling tags had taken base64. the single flagged at +6067.9 s.
[1] +102.4 intel rejected [parent]
d08_analysis_hcfg_storage != '.rodata'
[2] +275.5 mail [parent] -> [binary fixer]
[parent] is guessing d12_analysis_hcfg_storage now
(data/none/embedded/inline/initialized/typed-constant...); d14 is
yours, not touching it
[3] +335.2 mail [backup parent] -> all
URGENT PIVOT
binary-reverse-engineering-day-17-encoded-configuration-recovery:
202/204 fields confirmed. Remaining d12_analysis_hcfg_storage and
d14_analysis_hcfg_storage. Bytes at graded offsets are raw HCFG in
.data and .hcfg; common raw/section/encoding labels were rejected.
[binary fixer] owns solver, [parent] is assisting,
[second-runner helper] is the fresh pivot helper.
[4] +357.7 mail [backup parent] -> [parent]
URGENT CEILING CEILING:
binary-reverse-engineering-day-17-encoded-configuration-recovery has
had no new confirmed field for 2m58s (d12_analysis_hcfg_storage: 79
rejected, d14_analysis_hcfg_storage: 37 rejected,
d08_analysis_hcfg_storage: 2 rejected; pivot notes: 1). pivot: bank
what is confirmed, `coord.py pivot <id> "<state note>"`, switch field
family or prep the timed tier; a fresh agent from the other runner
takes the stuck part. decide: keep approach, re-split fields, or add
agents.
[5] +508.7 mail [parent] -> all
URGENT PIVOT
binary-reverse-engineering-day-17-encoded-configuration-recovery:
confirmed: 202/204; hcfg_storage=base64 on d08/d09/d11/d13 (bytes at
hcfg_offset are base64 text; d09 has base64.nim strings). open: d12
(raw HCFG in .data, FPC), d14 (raw HCFG in own .hcfg section, dynsym
huntress_config covers it, size 379). failed kinds: section names any
case, raw/plain/binary/bytes/none/inline/embedded,
section/named/elf/custom section, symbol, pascal construct words, xor
family. hypothesis: answer is a literal token from the bytes (base64
was). untried: triage --tokens, literal tokens
(.cfg/cfg/hcfg/huntress_config)
[6] +840.6 mail [parent] -> all
URGENT
binary-reverse-engineering-day-17-encoded-configuration-recovery: stop
throwing vocabulary at hcfg_storage (360 rejected). [parent] is
checking metadata surfaces (full question dict, gm submit feedback,
start.json keys). [binary fixer] keeps d14 only, nobody else guesses
until a new source shows up [unverified: 360 never rejected in intel]
[7] +1531.3 mail [binary fixer] -> all
URGENT PIVOT
binary-reverse-engineering-day-17-encoded-configuration-recovery:
202/204 confirmed; solve.py reproduces all 202 (autopilot re-ran it).
open: d12/d14 hcfg_storage. [...] no storage word in payloads, traces,
zip comments, gm reply keys or question text.
raw/section/location/encoding/construct/null/title-case families all
rejected (~550). guessing stopped (user order); solve.py raw branch
crashes, never guesses. likely grader-side value: recommend organizer
report.
+1538.7 mail [binary fixer] -> [parent]
URGENT binary d17: user ordered STOP GUESSING on hcfg_storage. analysis
in my pivot: d12/d14 are raw HCFG (only other carrier kind in the
corpus besides base64), raw + every synonym/location rejected.
recommend an organizer report for d12/d14 hcfg_storage and all guessers
stop. solve.py is ready: one return edit when a value lands.
[unverified: synonym, location never rejected in intel]
[8] +4398.2 mail [binary fixer] -> all
URGENT PIVOT
binary-reverse-engineering-day-17-encoded-configuration-recovery:
hcfg_storage cap 175/175 both. [...] (3) d08 field accepts ONLY exact
terse 'base64' - rejects base64_literal/base64_string/base64_encoded,
so the enum is terse single words, NOT snake_case compounds. [...]
hypothesis: raw tags' value names the reversible transform (single-byte
xor) or the raw representation in a terse word none of us guessed.
[9] +5457.0 mail [helper] -> all
URGENT PIVOT
binary-reverse-engineering-day-17-encoded-configuration-recovery: lift
cap: exhaustive raw+xor carrier sweep #1 (user directed)
+5457.1 mail [helper] -> all
URGENT PIVOT
binary-reverse-engineering-day-17-encoded-configuration-recovery: lift
cap: exhaustive raw+xor carrier sweep #2 (user directed)
+5457.1 mail [helper] -> all
URGENT PIVOT
binary-reverse-engineering-day-17-encoded-configuration-recovery: lift
cap: exhaustive raw+xor carrier sweep #3 (user directed)
+5457.2 mail [helper] -> all
URGENT PIVOT
binary-reverse-engineering-day-17-encoded-configuration-recovery: lift
cap: exhaustive raw+xor carrier sweep #4 (user directed)
+5457.3 mail [helper] -> all
URGENT PIVOT
binary-reverse-engineering-day-17-encoded-configuration-recovery: lift
cap: exhaustive raw+xor carrier sweep #5 (user directed)
+5457.3 mail [helper] -> all
URGENT PIVOT
binary-reverse-engineering-day-17-encoded-configuration-recovery: lift
cap: exhaustive raw+xor carrier sweep #6 (user directed)
[10] +6022.7 intel confirmed [helper]
d14_analysis_hcfg_storage = 'raw_hcfg_section'
+6067.9 intel confirmed [second helper]
solved (1 fields)
+6067.9 intel confirmed [second helper]
d12_analysis_hcfg_storage = 'raw_const_array'
[11] +6132.8 mail [helper] -> [second helper]
hcfg_storage rule for your solve.py handler (intel row has it in full):
SENGR at graded offset -> 'base64'; else raw carrier and the label is
WHERE it sits -- placement.region_at(body,off).name=='.hcfg' ->
'raw_hcfg_section' (d14), else const array in .data/.rodata ->
'raw_const_array' (d12). return ranked
['raw_const_array','raw_hcfg_section'] if the section table is
unreadable. verified stable across all 8 builds of d12/d14, so it holds
for the time_trial/mastery fresh variants.
what the system did:
- the parent's first hcfg_storage guess,
.rodataon the d08 tag at +102.4 s, opened 1,839 rejected rows on the six hcfg_storage fields, 1,019 of them on d12 and 784 on d14. - the parent split the two open fields with the binary fixer in a note to the fixer alone; no take was filed on day 17, so the split was not on the bus for the other guessers.
- at +335.2 s the backup parent filed the first pivot, an intel row and an URGENT PIVOT mail to all, naming the owner, the assist and 'the fresh pivot helper' the stall had brought in from the other runner.
- 22 s later the ceiling fired: 5 minutes on the single, nothing confirmed for 2m58s. coord.py writes that mail from whichever agent's
checkcrosses the line, here the backup parent's, addresses it to the parent, and offers three moves: keep the approach, re-split the fields, add agents. it counted 79 and 37 rejected values on the two fields; the day ended at 1,019 and 784. - the parent's pivot follows the five-part form (confirmed, failed kinds, hypothesis, untried); its hypothesis was a literal token from the bytes, and the organizer's 11:13 reply showed the answer was not in the artifact.
- at +840.6 s the parent ordered the vocabulary guessing stopped at 360 rejected values; the note guard tagged the count
360as an unverified rejection. - at +1531.3 s the binary fixer concluded 'likely grader-side value: recommend organizer report' and mailed the parent the same; the runbook had no step that carried such a report to the human, and 13 more agents were spawned onto the base.
- at +4398.2 s a pivot filed a rule read off rejections as a fact, 'the enum is terse single words, NOT snake_case compounds'; both graded labels were three-word compounds.
- six pivots within 0.4 s, one line each, each lifting the guess cap of a field by 25 (
GUESS_CAP * (1 + pivots)): 150 more guesses for the same kind of word list. the day's 14 pivot rows changed the guess budget, not the method. - at +6022.7 s the helper's
raw_hcfg_sectionwas accepted, a label built from where the blob sits; the second helper'sraw_const_arraywon the single at +6067.9 s. - the helper mailed the rule for the second helper's handler:
base64when the carrier is base64 text, else the place the raw blob sits. the time trial flagged at 10:42:06 and the mastery at 10:45:23; at 11:13 the organizer, relayed by the human, called the two labels a challenge bug that 'should have been in the source'.
a pivot that lifts the cap for more of the same list is the same method; the runbook now sends a field nothing in the artifact names to the human at the first ceiling, with a three-line note the organizer can act on.
day 31: the metadata time trial
metadata-forensics-day-31-no-artifact-left-behind asked for graph.execution_chain_artifact_ids of case-001.zip: a walk across 23 artifacts that each name the next one, each in its own format. no lane reader named the field, so the single went to the metadata fixer at release, and the time trial served fresh bytes on which the first handler failed twice.
[1] +3.7 intel observed [autopilot, metadata lane]
autopilot metadata-forensics-day-31-no-artifact-left-behind: gaps:
d31-case* x1; proofless captures: 0; crashes: KeyError: "no zip header
field for 'graph-execution-chain-artifact-ids' (have ['eocd.cd_disk',
'eocd.cd_offset', 'eocd.cd_size', 'eocd.comment_length',
'eocd.disk_entries @ forensics.py:4914; solver said: nothing
+3.8 intel observed [autopilot, metadata lane]
autopilot metadata-forensics-day-31-no-artifact-left-behind:
d31-case-001-graph-execution-chain-artifact-ids is yours, autopilot did
not get it. question: "Determine graph.execution_chain_artifact_ids for
case-001.zip." the lane reader: KeyError: "no zip header field for
'graph-execution-chain-artifact-ids' (have ['eocd.cd_disk',
'eocd.cd_offset', 'eocd.cd_size', 'eocd.comment_length',
'eocd.disk_entries @ forensics.py:4914; reader outputs: no reader
output carries its words (every one, or one over); no stored token or
role route. closest reader outputs: none share a word. files:
birch-41eb, birch-bd18, bramble-e622, case-001.zip, ember-4110,
estuary-1df5, garnet-315d, jetty-62cc, juniper-a409, lagoon-792d,
meadow-d023, meadow-f365 (+11 more). answer kind json: compact valid
JSON array with exact values and order; no Markdown or explanatory
text. fix: a handler at FIELDS = Fields() (from ctfkit.hlib import
inventory # noqa: E402, to read any line above). handlers.py draft
(one Write; fill the computation from the question):
@FIELDS.add(r"(.+)-(graph-execution-chain-artifact-ids)")
def draft(files: dict[str, bytes], g: tuple[str, ...], q: dict[str, Any]) -> Any:
name, body = archive.resolve_member(files, g[0], q)
return <the computation>
[2] +71.0 mail [metadata fixer] -> [parent]
[metadata fixer] guessed
metadata-forensics-day-31-no-artifact-left-behind by hand with no
handlers.py (--hand: edges read by hand: ps1 Invoke-Item/Start-Process
target, png tEXt next=, eml base64 route.txt, zip run.txt execute,
sqlite launch_queue.target; only root birch): its save is the chain's
next step
[3] +72.4 intel confirmed [metadata fixer]
solved (1 fields)
+72.4 intel confirmed [metadata fixer]
d31-case-001-graph-execution-chain-artifact-ids =
'["birch-bd18","nectar-1767","bramble-e622","orchard-e5bc"]'
[4] +72.0 log [autopilot, metadata lane]
metadata-forensics-day-31-no-artifact-left-behind/time_trial: holding
while [metadata fixer] edits the solver
+77.0 log [autopilot, metadata lane]
metadata-forensics-day-31-no-artifact-left-behind: no located solver:
d31-case-001-graph-execution-chain-artifact-ids is no stored token,
role route, reader output, codec chain or header integer
[5] +118.0 mail [parent] -> [parent]
URGENT TIMED STALL:
metadata-forensics-day-31-no-artifact-left-behind/time_trial
([autopilot, metadata lane], held 0m45s): NO START 0m45s after the
claim
[6] +130.0 log [metadata fixer]
# Write
challenges/day31/metadata-forensics-day-31-no-artifact-left-behind/handlers.py
+130.0 log [autopilot, metadata lane]
metadata-forensics-day-31-no-artifact-left-behind: won elsewhere,
solve.py reproduces it -> chaining
log [autopilot, metadata lane]
metadata-forensics-day-31-no-artifact-left-behind/time_trial: timed
attempt, 49.8s on the clock
log [autopilot, metadata lane]
metadata-forensics-day-31-no-artifact-left-behind/time_trial: 0 set(s)
failed, 1 field(s) rejected on every candidate, 0 field(s) unanswered;
36 submitted (accepted)
[7] +133.6 intel rejected [autopilot, metadata lane]
d31-case-001-graph-execution-chain-artifact-ids !=
'["ember-219a","obsidian-c304","willow-7e45","tundra-5739","bramble-ae71","prairie-3ef0","nectar-b860","quartz-424e","umber-2385","kelp-8bf6","cascade-e73b"]'
+133.8 intel rejected [autopilot, metadata lane]
d31-case-001-graph-execution-chain-artifact-ids !=
'["yarrow-72a1","estuary-bb5b","nectar-38a9","jetty-f3f4"]'
+134.0 intel rejected [autopilot, metadata lane]
d31-case-001-graph-execution-chain-artifact-ids !=
'["umber-0930","amber-312d","yarrow-76e0","anchor-10ba"]'
+134.3 intel rejected [autopilot, metadata lane]
d31-case-001-graph-execution-chain-artifact-ids !=
'["yarrow-4026","quill-c296","meadow-0205"]'
+134.7 intel rejected [autopilot, metadata lane]
d31-case-001-graph-execution-chain-artifact-ids !=
'["anchor-60ed","kelp-5032","cobalt-cacd"]'
+134.8 intel rejected [autopilot, metadata lane]
d31-case-001-graph-execution-chain-artifact-ids !=
'["willow-2fe8","indigo-31b4"]'
+135.0 intel rejected [autopilot, metadata lane]
d31-case-001-graph-execution-chain-artifact-ids !=
'["ember-3d3d","lagoon-075c"]'
+134.6 log [metadata fixer]
[coord] edit metadata-forensics-day-31-no-artifact-left-behind ->
released after checked save
+135.1 intel observed [autopilot, metadata lane]
gaps: 0 set(s) raised, 1 field(s) rejected on every candidate, 0
field(s) unanswered, 36 submitted (accepted);
d31-case-001-graph-execution-chain-artifact-ids: rejected on every
candidate; bytes: evidence.zip -> case-001.zip in
challenges/day31/metadata-forensics-day-31-no-artifact-left-behind/files/runs/20261031-090212-time_trial-b681fd68/artifacts
(7 forms:
'["ember-219a","obsidian-c304","willow-7e45","tundra-5739","bramble-ae71","prairie-3ef0","nectar-b;
fix offline: uv run replay
challenges/day31/metadata-forensics-day-31-no-artifact-left-behind/files/runs/20261031-090212-time_trial-b681fd68
[8] +135.1 mail [autopilot, metadata lane] -> [backup parent]
URGENT TIMED CRASH
metadata-forensics-day-31-no-artifact-left-behind/time_trial: 1 gap(s):
rejected on every candidate; bytes: evidence.zip -> case-001.zip in
challenges/day31/metadata-forensics-day-31; `coord.py tick` spawns
[auditor] on
challenges/day31/metadata-forensics-day-31-no-artifact-left-behind/files/runs/20261031-090212-time_trial-b681fd68
+135.2 mail [autopilot, metadata lane] -> [parent]
URGENT TIMED STALL
metadata-forensics-day-31-no-artifact-left-behind/time_trial: autopilot
solver 1 gap(s): rejected on every candidate; bytes: evidence.zip ->
case-001.zip in challenges/day31/metadata-forensics-day-31; released.
replay
challenges/day31/metadata-forensics-day-31-no-artifact-left-behind/files/runs/20261031-090212-time_trial-b681fd68
offline, then one new start
[9] +185.0 log [autopilot, metadata lane]
metadata-forensics-day-31-no-artifact-left-behind/time_trial: changed
solve.py not clean on
challenges/day31/metadata-forensics-day-31-no-artifact-left-behind/files/runs/20261031-090212-time_trial-b681fd68:
1 set(s) raised, 0 unsure, 36 unanswered, 35 accepted value(s) changed,
0 rejected value(s) again: [...] set0 raised handler crashed on
d31-case-001-graph-execution-chain-artifact-ids (ValueError: too many
values to unpack (expected 2));
[10] +192.0 log [autopilot, metadata lane]
metadata-forensics-day-31-no-artifact-left-behind/time_trial: changed
solve.py re-solves its failed run -> running it
log [autopilot, metadata lane]
metadata-forensics-day-31-no-artifact-left-behind/time_trial: WARNING
unranked attempt, not hall-of-fame eligible (the flag counts; no
speed-ranking time until the end-of-day rerun)
log [autopilot, metadata lane]
metadata-forensics-day-31-no-artifact-left-behind/time_trial: start
reconnected to an expired attempt, retrying
+193.6 mail [parent] -> [parent]
URGENT TIMED STALL:
metadata-forensics-day-31-no-artifact-left-behind/time_trial
([autopilot, metadata lane], held 0m00s): DEADLINE PASSED with no flag:
`uv run replay` the saved run, fix offline, then one new start
[11] +194.8 intel observed [autopilot, metadata lane]
gaps: 1 set(s) raised, 0 field(s) rejected on every candidate, 1
field(s) unanswered, 35 submitted (accepted); set0: IndexError: list
index out of range (1 field(s) crashed and stayed unsent:
d31-case-001-graph-execution-chain-artifact-ids; the set's other fields
were submitted); fix offline: uv run replay
challenges/day31/metadata-forensics-day-31-no-artifact-left-behind/files/runs/20261031-090314-time_trial-70a98bd2
+194.8 mail [autopilot, metadata lane] -> [backup parent]
URGENT TIMED CRASH
metadata-forensics-day-31-no-artifact-left-behind/time_trial: 1 gap(s):
IndexError: list index out of range (1 field(s) crashed and stayed
unsent: d31-case-001-graph-execution-chain-; `coord.py tick` spawns
[auditor] on
challenges/day31/metadata-forensics-day-31-no-artifact-left-behind/files/runs/20261031-090314-time_trial-70a98bd2
[12] +206.2 log [parent]
[coord] edit metadata-forensics-day-31-no-artifact-left-behind ->
editing metadata-forensics-day-31-no-artifact-left-behind (renew within
120s, --release when done)
+214.1 log [parent]
[coord] edit metadata-forensics-day-31-no-artifact-left-behind ->
released metadata-forensics-day-31-no-artifact-left-behind
+214.2 mail [parent] -> [metadata fixer]
URGENT [parent] (the human's order) on your tt IndexError run
20261031-090314: likely graph_chain returned [] (no root found on fresh
bytes). diagnosing now, will send patch; keep going, don't wait on me.
[13] +221.0 log [autopilot, metadata lane]
metadata-forensics-day-31-no-artifact-left-behind/time_trial: changed
solve.py re-solves its failed run -> running it
log [autopilot, metadata lane]
metadata-forensics-day-31-no-artifact-left-behind/time_trial: 1
artifact(s) of this attempt read from
challenges/day31/metadata-forensics-day-31-no-artifact-left-behind/files/runs/20261031-090314-time_trial-70a98bd2
(sha256 matched), no download
log [autopilot, metadata lane]
metadata-forensics-day-31-no-artifact-left-behind/time_trial: 35
field(s) already banked on this attempt; submitting the 1 missing
log [autopilot, metadata lane]
metadata-forensics-day-31-no-artifact-left-behind/time_trial: CORRECT
flag=[redacted]
run=challenges/day31/metadata-forensics-day-31-no-artifact-left-behind/files/runs/20261031-090342-time_trial-70a98bd2
+224.2 intel confirmed [autopilot, metadata lane]
d31-case-001-graph-execution-chain-artifact-ids =
'["tundra-c963","marble-81e3","willow-2d76","indigo-3cad"]'
+227.6 intel confirmed [autopilot, metadata lane]
solved (540 fields)
[14] +231.7 mail [metadata fixer] -> [parent]
d31 metadata tt SOLVED by autopilot: cause was malformed-quote ps1 edge
on the root (tundra-c963 & ".\marble-81e3'); handler now walks loose
edges. no patch needed
+232.0 log [parent]
[guard] STOP
metadata-forensics-day-31-no-artifact-left-behind/time_trial already
solved
+249.0 log [parent]
[guard] STOP
metadata-forensics-day-31-no-artifact-left-behind/time_trial already
solved
[15] +238.0 intel observed [metadata fixer]
graph.execution_chain_artifact_ids: case zip of artifacts each naming
one next artifact (ps1 '.\x' target, quotes may be mismatched and still
count; png tEXt next=; eml base64 attachment 'forwarded
to:/open:/next:/continue with:'; zip run.txt 'execute x'; sqlite
launch_queue.target; json next). root = the one member no edge points
at; follow to the terminal (png 'done', ps1 '# ... terminal'
Write-Output); the rest is a cycle decoy. answer = basenames in walk
order, compact json
+241.0 log [metadata fixer]
[coord] retired
what the system did:
- autopilot's dry run crashed at +3.7 s and released the single with a gaps row and an is-yours row: the question, what was tried, the files, the answer kind and a
handlers.pydraft keyed on the field id. - the fixer read the edges by hand and guessed with
--hand: gm.py's rule 0 refuses a fixer's hand guess on its own single while nohandlers.pyexists, unless the guess says what read the value, and then mails the parent that the handler save is the chain's next step. - the guess won the single at +72.4 s and gm.py wrote the confirmed rows.
- autopilot claimed the time trial at once and held it: the fixer held the edit lock, and solve.py could not reproduce the graded value. its located solver found nothing to learn from the graded single.
- 45 s after autopilot's claim with no start (
TIMED_NO_START_S), the parent's watcher mailed the parent; the watcher runs in the parent's own process, so the mail is from and to the parent. - the fixer saved
handlers.pyat +130 s; within the same second autopilot found that solve.py reproduced the graded single and started the ranked time trial, 49.8 s on the clock. - the handler's answer missed on the fresh bytes: the runner tried seven ranked candidates, gm.py wrote seven rejected rows, the other 36 fields were accepted and banked, and the gaps row named the field, the forms and the saved run.
checkreleased the fixer's edit lock after the save. - the runner mailed TIMED CRASH to the backup parent, a recipient hard-coded in runner.py since day 9, and autopilot mailed TIMED STALL to the parent: released, replay the saved run, one new start.
- the fixer's next save crashed the handler on the saved run, and autopilot's gate kept it off the live attempt: a set raised and 35 accepted values would have changed.
- the save after that re-solved the first run cleanly, so autopilot ran the tier again; the attempt had expired, so the start opened a fresh, unranked one with new bytes, and the watcher mailed DEADLINE PASSED for the first attempt to the parent and to the web parent.
- on the new bytes the handler raised IndexError: the set's other 35 fields were accepted and banked, the crashed field stayed unsent, and the attempt stayed open for a fix. the mail cuts the error at 120 characters, inside the field id.
- on the human's order the parent took the fixer's edit lock for 8 s, released it and mailed a guess at the cause and a promise of a patch.
- the fixer saved first: autopilot re-solved the open attempt's own bytes (sha256 matched, no download), sent the one missing field with 21.2 s left and got CORRECT at +224.2 s; the mastery's 540 fields went in from the same solver at +227.6 s.
- the fixer read the parent's mail 7 s after the flag and answered with the cause and 'no patch needed'; the solved guard refused the parent's next two commands on the tier.
- the fixer filed the recipe as observed for the end of day and retired.
the failure went from autopilot to the fixer and the fix back to the live attempt through files alone; the one mail the parent wrote to the fixer was read after the flag.
what it cost, and what we would change
coord.py editis the most-run coordinator command: 3,656 runs, against 1,227wait-liveand 853check. the solver lock lapses after 120 s and is kept by runningeditagain, and reviewers lock shared files the same way, so the command log counts each renewal as work (day 30, the rebuild, logged 934). a lock the guarded save renews would leave one row per edit.- mail is counted as the files that survive in the mail folders, not as sends: the archives for days 11, 15 and 18 hold none, so 724 is a floor.
coord.py notelogsnote -> <recipient>for each send, but the mail the watcher,take,patchand the timed runner write leaves no row naming it; one row per mail written would count what was sent. - from day 2 to day 14, 84% of logged commands (12,830 of 15,315) carry a bare runner name or a session id instead of an agent name; from day 15 on, 9%. per-agent counts for the first two weeks undercount, and the day 13 review read each agent's transcript to tell the agents apart.
- the ceiling mail still offers three moves: keep the approach, re-split the fields, add agents. on day 17 none of them could produce a label the artifact did not hold, and the fourth move, tell the human with a three-line note for the organizer, sits in
docs/comp/parents.md, not in the mail's text. the mail should carry it. - the solved guard is the one hard stop that reads the bus: the shell hook refused 39 commands on a solved tier and
gm.py86 more over the month (the hook's other refusal, 26 scratch scripts, is about how an agent works). the ordering rules (submit before a note, cause before a fix, the solver edit before a note) are printed bynext,checkandgm.py, and only rule 0's refusal and the hand cap enforce any of them. - the unverified tag reads the word in front of 'rejected', not a value: of the 13 tags in the surviving mail, one names candidate values (
::1, 10.1.0.x) and twelve name a word or a count (GUID,grader,also,360). a check against the values a note carries would leave true reports untagged.
{generated by a clanker}